How palliative care programs can dig into existing data to reveal opportunities and improve health equity within their organizations.

Identify and Measure Gaps in Care

One of my favorite quirky TV shows some years ago was “The Detectorists” about oddballs with metal detectors combing the English countryside with the hope of finding valuable, historic, or even priceless items.

Did you ever wish that you had a “Disparity Detectorist” who could help you find gaps or disparities in your palliative care program or its outcomes? That could certainly be valuable, perhaps even priceless!

The truth is anyone can be a Disparity Detectorist.

Key Term: Health disparities (“disparities”) are avoidable differences in health outcomes that are driven by social, structural, and historical factors.

Start with Your Existing Data

To care for patients well—and to use limited resources wisely—palliative care teams rely on a core set of data. This includes who is being served (e.g., age, diagnosis, or clinical complexity) as well as how care is delivered (e.g., referral sources, proportion of admissions seen, and the type and frequency of services provided).

For any process of palliative care or relevant outcome that you are measuring, you can (and should!) also assess whether there are disparities or gaps. Any metric or data element can be “sliced and diced” for possible gaps in delivery or outcomes of palliative care or opportunities for improvement. Such disparities or gaps may be regarding patient characteristics—such as age (e.g., pediatric), race, ethnicity, language, location (e.g., rurality), insurance type, or primary clinical condition. Or they may be about your health system, such as the site of care (e.g., which hospital or clinic/office), geographic regions, or degree of financial risk (e.g., your Medicare Advantage plan versus fee-for-service).

Easy examples are any metrics you have about the use or timeliness of specialty palliative care:

Hospital stays for patients with advanced serious illness: Community-based palliative care use among patients with serious illnesses:
  • Are there disparities in who used inpatient palliative care, or in how timely it was relative to admission date?
  • How about in time from referral to actual consultation, or proportion that are too late (e.g., patient discharged or died) or refused?
  • Who has access to your clinic-based and home-based palliative care services?
  • Who doesn’t?
  • Of those who do, who uses it, and are there differences in the duration or frequency of encounters?

Beyond the Basics

More challenging examples might involve outcomes. Do different patient populations have different experiences or outcomes from your palliative care services? How can you detect that?

  • Patient experience data: If you’re collecting inpatient, clinic, or home-based patient experience data, you could slice and dice by patient characteristics. Are there differences in the degree to which patients rate their feelings of being heard and understood, or satisfaction with symptom control?
  • Goal-concordant care data: Among the patients for whom you have POLST or ACP [MB3] [BC4] documentation, does the degree of concordance between their expressed wishes and their subsequent care differ by patient characteristics?
  • Clinical data: If you’re collecting ESAS (Edmonton Symptom Assessment System) or other clinical data, have you examined it by patient characteristics, either for differences in initial symptom burden or for changes in symptoms after palliative care was initiated?
  • Opioid management data: If you can leverage your prescription data, you can evaluate practices such as co-prescription of opioids and naloxone, or opioids and benzodiazepines. Or you could evaluate patients’ Morphine Milligram Equivalent Daily Dose (MMED) over time, how often urine drug screens or similar tests are ordered. For any such data, you can also slice and dice by patient characteristics.
  • Disenrollment data: For programs such as home-based palliative care or hospice, disenrollment rates by patient characteristics can indicate differences in dissatisfaction with services or, in some cases, the suspension of services by providers.
  • Palliative-adjacent outcomes: If your health system is measuring outcomes such as in-hospital mortality or re-admissions, encourage them to take a Disparity Detectorist approach to those as well. For whom are you seeing the highest or lowest rates?

A mantra to consider adopting would be: “If something is worth measuring, then it’s worth evaluating for disparities or gaps.”

The hard part in most organizations is setting up the capabilities for doing the initial measurement—consider collaborating with your organization’s data analytics or IT departments. “Slicing and dicing” by patient or health system characteristics is then relatively easy.

But the hardest part requires some expertise and wisdom: not just whether you detected something but discerning what it means. Is it valuable? In terms of differences among patients, is it just a difference or does it represent a gap or disparity? This is especially important in preference-sensitive health care behaviors such as the desire to use life-sustaining therapies, use of the hospital as a place of death, or the extent to which hospice is embraced. For example, among patients who complete POLST, some may be more likely to forgo life-sustaining therapies than other patients. That kind of difference in preference may be useful to know, but is it problematic? Does it need to be fixed?

So, another mantra may also be worth adopting: “Before you start slicing and dicing, how will you interpret the results, and which ones will you decide ahead of time are actionable?”

Additional Resources

Get the latest updates in your inbox!